|
Appendix A: List of all inscriptions
(Table)
Abbreviations
used for the references in the list of inscriptions.
|
Cao
(1999): Cao Jinyan 曹錦炎,
Niaochongshu tongkao 鳥蟲書通考 (Shanghai:
Shuhua chubanshe, 1999).
|
|
Cao
(2007): Cao Jinyan 曹錦炎,
Wu Yue lishi yu kaogu luncong 吳越歷史與考古論叢 (Beijing: Wenwu
chubanshe, 2007).
|
|
Cao
(2014): Cao Jinyan 曹錦炎,
Niaochongshu tongkao 鳥蟲書通考 (Revised and
expanded Edition, 增訂版)
(Shanghai: Shanghai cishu chubanshe, 2014).
|
|
Dong
(1992): Dong Chuping 董楚平,
Wu Yue Xu Shu jinwen jishi 吳越徐舒金文集释 (Hangzhou: Zhejiang guji chubanshe,
1992).
|
|
Dong
(1998): Dong Chuping 董楚平,
Wu Yue wenhua zhi 吳越文化志 (Shanghai: Shanghai renmin chubanshe, 1998).
|
|
Dong
Shan: Dong Shan 董珊,
Wu Yue timing yanjiu 吳越題銘研究 (Beijing: Kexue chubanshe, 2014).
|
|
Feng:
Feng Puren 馮普仁. Wu Yue
wenhua 吳越文化. Beijing: Wenwu
chubanshe, 2007.
|
|
Lin, Lin Chin-Chung (Lin Jinzhong) 林進忠,
“Dong Zhou niaochongshu de wenzi zaoxing yishu” 東周鳥蟲書的文字造形藝術, Shuhua
yishu xue kan 書畫藝術學刊, # 2 (2007): 1-31.
|
|
Milburn:
Olivia Milburn, Cherishing Antiquity: The Cultural Construction of an
Ancient Chinese Kingdom (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2013).
|
|
Rong
(1934): Rong Geng 容庚,
“Niaoshu kao” 鳥書考.
Yanjng xuebao 燕京學報 16 (1934), 195-204.
|
|
Rong
(1935): Rong Geng 容庚,
“Niaoshu kao buzheng” 鳥書考補正. Yanjng xuebao 燕京學報 17 (1935), 173-178
|
|
Rong
(1964): Rong Geng 容庚,
“Niaoshu kao” 鳥書考,
in Rong Geng Wenji 容庚文集 (Guangdong: Zhongshan daxue chubanshe, 1964),
274-319.
|
|
Shi:
Shi Xiejie 施谢捷, Wu Yue
wenzi huibian 吳越文字彙編
(Nanjing: Jiangsu jiaoyu chubanshe, 1998).
|
|
Wang:
Wang Jiehua 王結華, Mao Ying 毛穎, and Liu Liwen 劉麗文, Gu Yue
yizhen yanjiu 古越遺珍研究
(Beijing: Kexue chubanshe 科學出版社, 2010).
|
|
Zhang
and Cao: Zhang Guangyu 張光裕
and Cao Jinyan 曹錦炎,
Dongzhou niaozhuan wenzi bian 東周鳥篆文字編 (Hong Kong:
Hanmoxuan chuban youxian gongsi, 1994).
|
Wu 吳 Inscriptions,
early and Later
|
Name
of Artifact
|
Provenance
and present
location
(NB:
"excavated" is not "Found" or "Unearthed")
|
References
Listed
in chronological order
NB:
# = item number
|
|
EARLY WEAPONS
|
|
A. Weapons from 585–561 BCE, the reign of King Shoumeng 壽夢
|
|
*1. “Sword of Prince
Gufa Zhufan, Son of the King of Gouwu” 工䱷大子姑發[聑over𠔼]反劍
(Jicheng, 18.11718).
|
Excavated 1959.
Zhanguo, Tomb No.2 二號墓 (M2:18.6), N of Cai Family Hill 蔡家崗, Zhao family burial mound 趙家孤堆,
Huainan 淮南, Anhui. Current location: Anhui
Provincial Museum, Hefei.
|
1. Kaogu (1963.4),
204-212.
2. Dong (1992),
89-92.
3. Shi, 539-40 [#42].
4. Feng, 120.
5. Dong Shan, 9 [#1].
|
|
B. Weapons from 560–548 BCE, the reign of King Zhufan 諸樊
|
|
*1. “Dagger-axe of
King Gufa Zhufan of Gouwu” 工𫊣王姑癹者坂戈.
|
Excavated 1995. Tomb
No.41, Jiuligou 九里溝, Lu’an 六安.
Current location: site report does not specify.
|
1. Wenwu yanjiu
文物研究.
13 (2001):
320-21.
2. Dong Shan, 10
[#3].
|
|
*1. “Sword of the
Younger Brother of King Gufa Zhufan of Gouwu”
工𫊣王姑癹 [日
in between 北 over 舌]反之弟劍.
|
Excavated 1985.
Sanjiaoping 三角坪, NE of city area of Yushe County
榆社縣縣城東北, Shanxi. Current location: Yushe
County Museum 榆社縣博物館, Shanxi.
|
1. Wenwu
(1990.2): 77-79,
Figs. 2 and 3.
2. Dong (1992),
94-98.
3. Shi, 540 [#43].
4. Cao (2007), 10-13.
5. Feng, 121.
6. Dong Shan, 10
[#6].
|
|
*2. “Sword of Tong,
the Son of King Gufa Zhufan of Gouwu” 攻敔王姑發者反之子通劍.
|
Excavated 2003.
Eastern Zhou Tomb No.11, Zhou jiazhuang 周家莊,
Xintai City 新泰, Shandong. Current location:
Xintai Museum 新泰市博物館, Shandong.
|
1. Zhongguo lishi
wenwu 中國歷史文物 (2004.5): 15-23.
2. Zhongguo wenwu
bao 中國文 物報
(2003.11): 83-90.
3. Huaxia kaogu
華夏考古 (2013.6): 95-96.
4. Dong Shan,10 [#4].
|
|
*3. “Sword of
Caoyinyuan, the Son of the King Gufa of Wu” 攻𫊣王姑發之子曹斦員劍.
|
Scientifically
excavated in 1982; Ancient burial at No.6 Brick and Tile Factory 磚瓦廠, Xiangfan 襄樊 city,
Hubei. Current location: Hubei Provincial Museum 湖北省博物館.
|
1. Wenwu
(1998.6): 90-92.
2. Feng, 121
3. Dong Shan, 10
[#5].
|
|
*4. “Sword of the
King of Gouwu” 工䱷王劍 (Jicheng, 18.11665).
|
Excavated 1983.
Chunqiu tomb 春秋墓, Luetuan village 略疃村, Zhuge village 諸葛鄉,
Yishui沂水, Shandong. Current location:
Yishui Museum 沂水縣博物館, Shandong.
|
1. Wenwu 12
(1983.12): 12,
Fig. 2.
2. Dong (1992),
92-94.
3. Shi, 540-1 [#44].
4. Feng, 120.
5. Dong Shan, 9 [#2].
|
|
C. Weapons from 547–544 BCE, The reign of
King Yuji 余祭
|
|
“Dagger-axe of King
Qiegouciyu of the Gouwu”
攻𫊣王[虘+又][句+戈]此[余over車+阝]之鑄戈
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private Collection in Jiangxi.
|
Dong Shan, 13 [#9].
|
|
*1. “Sword of King
Qiegouciyu of the Gouwu” 攻𫊣王囗囗 [虘+又][句+戈]此䣄劍
|
Unearthed in 1988 in
a mudslide in Gucheng 榖城, Hubei. Current location:
Gucheng Museum 榖城博物館, Hubei.
|
1. Kaogu
(2000.4): 95-96.
2. Feng, 121.
3. Dong Shan, 12
[#7].
|
|
2. “Sword of King
Qiegouciyu of the Gouwu” 攻𫊣王虘[丩+戈]此䣄劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
|
1. Jianghan kaogu
(2009.3): 81- 84.
2. Dong Shan, 13
[#8].
|
|
3. “Sword of
Qieyigouyu, Younger Brother of the King of the Gouwu” 工𫊣大虘矣工𫊣劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Poly Art Museum 保利藝術博物館,
Beijing
|
1. Dong Shan, 13
[#10].
|
|
4. “Sword of
Qieyigouyu, Younger Brother of the King of the Gouwu” 工𫊣大弔虘矣工𫊣劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection, Beijing
|
1. Dong Shan, 13
[#11].
|
|
5. “Sword of King
Qieyigouyu of the Gouwu” 工𫊣王虘矣工𫊣劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Hangzhou?
|
1. Cao, Jiang Han
kaogu 江漢考古 (2009.3).
2. Dong Shan, 13
[#12].
|
|
D. Weapons from 543–527 BCE, the reign of King Yumei 餘眛
|
|
*1. “Spear of Gouwu” 工𫊣矛
|
Excavated 1984,
Chunqiu tomb 春秋墓 (M79), on top of a hill North of
Dantu County 丹徒縣北山頂, Jiangsu. Current location:
Nanjing Museum 南京博物館.
|
1. Dong (1992),
101-103.
2. Shi, 541 [#45].
3. Dong Shan, 15-16
[#13].
|
|
“Sword of the Son of
King Shoumeng of Wu” 吳王壽夢之子劍.
|
Unearthed in 1997.
Shaoxing, Zhejiang. Current location: Shaoxing Yue Culture Museum 紹興越文化博物館.
|
1. Cao Jinyan, Wenwu
(2005.2):
67-74.
2. Li Jiahao 李金浩 (2007),
293-308.
3. Feng, 120.
4. Milburn, 125.
5. Dong Shan, 21
[#14].
|
|
E. Weapons of the Son of Prince JiZha
|
|
1. Sword of the
Cheng, the Son of (Prince) Jizi of Wu 吳季子之子逞劍
(Jicheng, 18.11640).
|
17th century,
“Found.” Originally, in the collection of Sun Chengze 孫承澤 (1592-1676). Now lost.
|
1. Wang Shizhen
(1669).
2. Wang Shizhen
(1701).
3. Ruan Yuan.
4. Rong (1934): 198,
Fig. 4.
5. Perceval Yetts,
547-52,
Fig. 1.
6. Rong (1964),
285-86; 304,
Fig. 19.
7. Dong (1992),
98-99.
8. Shi, 541 [#46].
9. Lin, 25 [#135].
10. Cao (2014), 66,
Fig. 43,
69 [Wu #9].
11. Dong Shan, 23
[#15].
|
|
“Sword of [Cheng],
the Son of Jizi of Wu” 吳季子之子[逞]劍
|
Salvaged in 1971 at a
junkyard 廢品收購站, Sanyuan County, Shaanxi.
Current location: Sanyuan Museum 三原縣博物館,
Shaanxi.
|
1. Wenbo 文博
(1996.8): 86-
91.
2. Dong Shan, 23
[#16].
|
|
F. Weapons from 526-515 BCE, the reign of King
Liao
|
|
1. “Dagger-Axe of
Prince Yu” 王子[于+欠]戈
(Jicheng, 17.11207).
|
Excavated 1961, Jia
Family Ya (Cliff) 賈家崖, near Houtumiao Village 后土廟村, Wanrong County 萬榮縣,
Shanxi. Current location: Shanxi Provincial Museum 山西省博物館.
|
1. Wenwu 文物
4 and 5 (1962): 5, Figs. 1-3.
2. Rong (1964),
283-84; 305.
Fig. 16.
3. Dong (1992),
122-31.
4. Zhang and Cao, 200
[#40].
5. Shi, 545 [#57].
6. Cao (1999), 42,
Fig. 19.
7. Cao (2014), 57-59,
Fig. 35,
58 [Wu #1].
8. Lin, 21 [#040].
9. Dong Shan, 34
[#17].
Feng, 121.
|
|
2. “Dagger-Axe of
Prince Yu” 王子[于+欠]戈
(Jicheng, 17.11208).
|
Same as above
|
1. Wenwu 4 and
5 (1962.4 and
5): Figs. 1-3.
2. Zhang and Cao, 201
[#41].
3. Shi, 546 [#58].
4. Cao (1999), 44,
Fig. 20.
5. Lin, 21, [#041].
6. Cao (2014), 58
[#3].
7. Dong Shan, 34
[#18].
|
|
G.
Other Assorted Early Weapons Associated with Wu
|
|
1. “Gong[wu] dashu
[shi]nünao ge” 工大弔女夒戈
|
Provenance Unknown.
|
1. Xiao Chunyuan
2008.
2. Dong Shan, 82
[#182].
|
|
II.
Later Wu Weapons from (514-473 BCE)
|
|
A.
Weapons from 514-496 BCE, King Guang光 (r. 514-496 BCE; aka King Helu 闔廬/Helü 闔閭)
|
|
1. “Dagger-axe of
King Guang of Gouwu” 攻敔王光戈 (Jicheng, 17.11151).
|
Unprovenanced, said
to be from Jin Village 金村, Luoyang 洛陽, Henan. Originally in the
collection of Yu Xingwu 于省吾 (1896-1984). Current location:
Palace Museum 故宮博物院, Beijing.
|
1. Rong (1935):
174-175 [#24].
2. Rong (1964),
284-5; 307,
Fig. 18.
3. Dong (1992),
114-116.
4. Zhang and Cao,
192-193
[#36].
5. Shi, #47, 541-2.
6. Cao (1999), 45,
Fig. 21.
7. Lin, 21 [#036].
8. Cao (2014), 59-62;
Fig. 37,
61 [Wu #3].
9. Dong Shan, #23.
|
|
2. “Dagger-axe of
King Guang of Gouwu” 攻敔王光戈 (Jicheng, 17.11029).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Originally in the collection of Qu Zhongrong 瞿中溶
(1769-1842). Current location: Unknown
|
1. Zhang and Cao,
#152, 330.
2. Dong (1992), 116.
3. Shi, 542 [#48].
4. Lin, 25 [#152].
5. Dong Shan, 28
[#22].
|
|
3. “Dagger-axe of
Dawang Guangyuan” 大王光𧻚戈
(Jicheng, 17.11255).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Originally in the collection of the Jin 金
family from Songjiang 松江, and Zheng 鄭
family of Shunde 順德. Current location: Shanghai
Museum.
|
1. Rong (1964), 284;
306, Fig.
#17.
2. Dong (1992),
117-122.
3. Zhang and Cao, 197
[#39].
4. Lin, 21 [#039].
5. Shi, 543 [#51].
6. Cao (1999), 48,
Fig. 24.
7. Cao (2014), 63;
Fig. 40, 65
[Wu #6].
8. Dong Shan, 29
[#26].
|
|
4. “Dagger-axe of
Dawang Guangyuan” 大王光𧻚戈
(Jicheng, 17.11256).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Originally in the collection of Qu Zhongrong 瞿中溶
(1769-1842). Current location: unknown.
|
1. Dong (1992),
117-122.
2. Zhang and Cao, 198
[#151].
3. Shi, 542-3 [#50].
4. Cao (1999), 51,
Fig. 26.
5. Lin, 25 # [151].
6. Cao (2014), 66;
Figs. 42, 68
[Wu #8].
7. Dong Shan, 29
[#25].
|
|
5. “Dagger-axe of
Dawang Guangyuan” 大王光𧻚戈
(Jicheng, 17.11257).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Originally in the collection of He Jiaxiang 何嘉祥
of Hangzhou. Current location: Whereabouts unknown
|
1. Dong (1992),
117-122.
2. Zhang and Cao,
#38, 195-
96.
3. Shi, 542 [#49,].
4. Cao (1999), 50,
Fig. 25.
5. Lin, 21 [#038].
6. Cao (2014),
63-66.; Fig. 41,
67 [Wu #7].
7. Dong Shan (2014),
29 [#24].
|
|
*1. “Sword of King
Guang of Gouwu” 攻敔王光劍 (Jicheng,18.11620).
|
Excavated 1964. Jin
tomb 晉國墓, Shiyu Village 峙峪村, Yuanping County 原平縣,
Shanxi. Current location: Shanxi Provincial Museum 山西省博物館.
|
1. Dong (1992), 106.
2. Shi (1998), 543
[#52].
3. Feng, 122.
4. Dong Shan, 31
[#32].
|
|
*2. “Sword of King
Guang of Gouwu” 攻敔王光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11666).
|
Excavated 1974.
Biangang village 邊崗村, Tangchi xiang-village 湯池鄉, Lujiang County 廬江縣,
Anhui. Current location: Anhui Provincial Museum 安徽省博物館,
Hefei.
|
1. Wenwu 文物
(1986.2): 64, Fig. 2.
2. Dong (1992),
109-113.
3. Shi, 544-5 [#55].
4. Feng, 122.
5. Dong Shan, 31
[#33].
|
|
*3. “Sword of King
Guang of Gouwu” 攻敔王光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11654).
|
Excavated 1978. Tomb
in Nanling County 南陵縣, Wuhu 蕪湖,
Anhui. Current location: Nanling Musuem 南陵縣博物館,
Anhui
|
1. Wenwu (1982.5):
59.
2. Wenwu
(1982.8): 69.
3. Dong (1992),
107-108.
4. Shi, 543-4 [#54].
5. Feng, 122.
6. Dong Shan, 29
[#28].
|
|
4. “Sword of King
Guang of Gouwu” 攻敔王光劍 (1993).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Unearthed in 1993. Anji 安吉, Zhejiang. Current location:
Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
1. Zhang and Cao, 149
[#37].
2. Shi, 543 [#53].
3.Cao (1999), 47,
Fig. 23.
4.Lin, 21 [#037].
5. Cao (2014), 63;
Fig. 39, 64 [Wu # 5].
6. Dong Shan, #31.
|
|
5. Sword of King
Guanghan of Gouwu 攻敔王光韓劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Sackler Museum, Harvard
|
1. Dong (1992), 140.
2. Shi, 545 [#56].
3. Dong Shan, 29
[#27].
|
|
6. Sword of King
Guangyuan of Wu 吳王光𧻚劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection, Beijing.
|
Dong Shan, 30 [#29].
|
|
7. Sword of King
Guang of Gouwu 攻敔王光劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection of Wang Zhengua 王振華,
Gu Yuege臺北古越閣 (“Ancient Yue Pavilion”), Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Dong Shan, 30 [#30].
|
|
8. “Sword of King
Zheji ?? of Wu” 吳王者彶[虘+又]虜劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Wuxi Museum 無錫博物館.
|
1. Jiang Han kaogu
(2009.3): 81-84.
2. Dong Shan, 31
[#34].
|
|
1. “The Belt Hook of
King Guang of the Gouwu” 工吾王光帶鉤
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shaoxing Yuewenhua Museum 紹興越文化博物館
|
Dong Shan, 32 [#35].
|
|
2. “The Belt Hook of
King Guang of the Gouwu”工吾王光帶鉤
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location:
|
Dong Shan, 32 [#36].
|
|
3. “The Belt Hook of
the Son of the King of the Gouwu” 吳王之子帶鉤
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location:
|
Dong Shan, #37
|
|
4. “The Belt Hook of
King Zhang […] of the Gouwu” 吳王長囗帶鉤 (Jicheng, 10406).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection, Hangzhou
|
1. Dong Shan, 32 [#38].
|
|
5. “The Belt Hook of
the King of the Gouwu” 攻吾王帶鉤
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location:
|
1. Cao Jinyan, Dongnan
wenhua
(2013.2): 90-93.
2. Dong Shan, 32-3
[#39].
|
|
6. “The Belt Hook of
Shangou the Wu” 吳上鉤帶鉤
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection
|
Dong Shan, 33 [#40].
|
|
B. Weapons of King Fuchai 夫差
|
|
*1. “Dagger-axe of
King Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差戈 (Jicheng, 17.11288).
|
Excavated 1959,
Zhanguo tomb No. 2 二號墓, N of Cai Family Hill 蔡家崗, Zhao family burial mound 趙家孤堆,
Huainan 淮南, Anhui. Current location: Anhui
Provincial Museum 安徽省博物館, Hefei 合肥.
|
1. Kaogu
(1963.4): 205, Figs. 1, 2; plate 3:7.
2. Kaogu
(1965.9): 465, Fig. 1.
3. Dong (1992),
132-33.
4. Shi, 542 [#50].
5. Dong Shan, 37
[#50].
Feng, 123.
|
|
1. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍 (Jicheng, 18.11636).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Unknown.
|
1. Dong (1992),
141-146.
2. Shi, 549-50 [#74].
3. Dong Shan, 38
[#53].
|
|
2. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍 (Jicheng, 18.11637).
|
Unearthed in 1935,
inside the West gate 西門內, Shou County 壽縣,
Anhui. Current location: National
Museum of China 中國國家博物館, Beijing.
|
1. Dong (1992),
135-136.
2. Shi, 550 [#76].
3. Feng, 123.
4. Dong Shan, 38
[#61].
|
|
3. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍 (Jicheng, 18.11638).
|
Unearthed in the
early 20th century from an Eastern Zhou cemetery at Liuli pavilion
琉璃閣, southeast of Hui County 輝縣,
Henan. Salvaged in 1976 at a junkyard 廢品回收部門
in Baiquan 百泉, Hui County, Henan. Current
location: Hui County, Baiquan Cultural Relic Safeguarding Division 輝縣百泉文物保管所, Hui County 輝縣,
Henan.
|
1. Wenwu (1976.11):
Plate 4:4.
2. Dong (1992), 137.
3. Shi, 550-1 [#78].
4. Feng, 123.
5. Dong Shan, 39
[#62].
|
|
4. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Salvaged in 1965 at
junk yard 廢品收購站, Pingdu County 平度縣, Shandong. Current location: Shandong Provincial
Museum 山東省博物館.
|
1. Dong (1992),
138-9.
2. Shi, 550 [#77]
3. Feng, 123.
4. Dong Shan, 38
[#57].
|
|
*5. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍 (Jicheng, 18.11639).
|
Excavated 1976. Chu
tomb No. 12 at Caipo 蔡坡, Xiangyang County 襄陽縣, Hubei Current location: Hubei Provincial Museum 湖北省博物館, Wuhan 武漢.
|
1. Wenwu
(1976.11): Plate 4:1.
2. Dong (1992),
139-40.
3. Shi, #79, 551.
4. Dong Shan, 39
[#63].
5. Feng, 123.
|
|
6. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍 (1991).
|
Unearthed in 1991;
North of Zhu shanzhuang Village 朱山莊村,
Chengguan Township 城關鎮, Zou County 鄒縣,
Shandong. Current location: Zou County Cultural Relic Safeguarding Division 鄒縣文物保管所.
|
1. Wenwu
(1993.8): 72-73. Fig.
4 and 5.
2. Shi, 551 [#80].
3. Feng, 123.
4. Dong Shan, 39 #65.
|
|
*7. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Excavated 1991.
Zhanguo Tomb 墓 (C1M3352), Zhongzhou street 中州中路, Luoyang 洛陽, Henan
Current location: Luoyang Museum 洛陽市博物館,
Henan.
|
1. Dong (1992), 149.
2. Shi, 551 [#81].
3. Feng, 123.
4. Dong Shan, 38
[#55].
|
|
8. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Whereabouts unknown.
|
1. Dong (1992), 147-8.
2. Shi, 550 [#75].
3. Dong Shan, 38
[#52].
|
|
9. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection, Wang Zhenhua 王振華,
Gu Yue ge 古越閣 (“Ancient Yue Pavilion”), Taipei,
Taiwan.
|
1. Shi, 551 [#82].
2. Dong Shan, 39
[#64].
|
|
10. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Tianjin Art Museum 天津藝術博物館.
|
1. Dong (1992), 140.
2. Shi, 551 [#83].
3. Dong Shan, 39
[#66].
|
|
11. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection, Hong Kong
|
1. Shi, 552 [#84].
2. Dong Shan, 38
[#58].
|
|
12. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection, Hong Kong
|
1. Shi, 552 [#85].
2. Dong Shan, 38
[#59].
|
|
13. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection, Taiwan.
|
1. Shi, 552 [#86].
2. Dong Shan, 39
[#67].
|
|
14. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection in Beijing.
|
Dong Shan, 38 [#54].
|
|
15. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection in Anhui.
|
Dong Shan, 38 [#56].
|
|
16. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Art Museum of the Chinese University of Hong Kong 香港中文大學文物館.
|
Dong Shan, 38 [#60].
|
|
17. “Sword of King
Fuchai of Gouwu” 攻敔王夫差劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shaoxing Museum 紹興縣博物館.
|
|
|
*1. “Spear of King
Fuchai of Wu” 吳王夫差矛 (Jicheng, 18.115343).
|
Excavated 1983; Chu
Tomb No.5 五號楚墓, Mashan 馬山,
Jiangling County 江陵縣, Hubei. Current location: Hubei
Provincial Museum 湖北省博物館.
|
1. Dong (1992),
133-4.
2. Shi, 552 [#87].
3. Feng, 123.
4. Dong Shan, 37
[#51].
|
|
*1. “Halberd of
[Fu]chai of Gouwu” 攻敔工差戟 (Jicheng, 17.11258).
|
Excavated 1980,
burial on a small hill 小山墓葬, 18 pavilion 十八塔, shangyuan street 上元街,
Nanyue 南獄, Huoshan County 霍山縣, Anhui. Current location: Huoshan County Cultural
Relic Division 霍山縣文物組.
|
1. Wenwu
(1986.3): 44,
Fig. 1-4.
2. Dong (1992),
99-101.
3. Shi, 552-3 [#88].
4. Feng, 121
5. Dong Shan, 36
[#49].
|
|
III. Bells
|
|
1. The Bells of
Prince Zhejian 者减 of Wu
|
|
a. Bell of Prince
Zhejian 者减鐘 (Jicheng, 1.193).
|
Qianlong 乾隆
year 26 (1761); Linjiang 臨江, Jiangxi (present-day Qingjiang
County 清江縣). Current location: Unknown
|
Jicheng, 1.193.
Dong Chuping (1992),
26-39.
Shi (1998), #1, 523.
Feng, 120.
|
|
b. Bell of Prince
Zhejian 者减鐘 (Jicheng, 1.194).
|
Same as above.
Current location: Unknown
|
Jicheng, 1.194.
Dong Chuping (1992),
26-39.
Shi (1998), # 2, 523.
|
|
c. Bell of Prince
Zhejian 者减鐘 (Jicheng, 1.195).
|
Same as above.
Current location: Unknown
|
Jicheng, 1.195.
Dong Chuping (1992),
26-39.
Shi (1998), #3, 523.
|
|
d. Bell of Prince
Zhejian 者减鐘 (Jicheng, 1.196).
|
Same as above.
Current location: Unknown
|
Jicheng, 1.196.
Dong Chuping (1992),
26-39.
Shi (1998), #4,
523-4.
|
|
e. Bell of Prince
Zhejian 者减鐘 (Jicheng, 1.197).
|
Same as above.
Current location: Academia Sinica Museum 臺北中央博物館,
Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Jicheng,1.197.
Dong Chuping (1992),
26-39.
Shi (1998), # 5, 524.
Dong Shan (2014),
#68A-B.
|
|
f. Bell of Prince
Zhejian 者减鐘 (Jicheng, 1.198).
|
Same as above.
Current location: National Palace Museum 臺北故宮博物院,
Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Jicheng, 1.198.
Dong Chuping (1992),
26-39.
Shi (1998), #6,
524-6.
Dong Shan (2014),
#68C-D.
|
|
g. Bell of Prince
Zhejian 者减鐘 (Jicheng, 1.199).
|
Same as above.
Current location: Unknown
|
Jicheng,1.199.
Dong Chuping (1992),
26-39.
Shi (1998), #7, 526.
|
|
h. Bell of Prince
Zhejian 者减鐘 (Jicheng, 1.200).
|
Same as above.
Current location: Unknown
|
Jicheng,1.200.
Dong Chuping (1992),
26-39.
Shi (1998), #8, 526.
|
|
i. Bell of Prince
Zhejian 者减鐘 (Jicheng, 1.201).
|
Same as above.
Current location: Previously in the collection of Huang Jun黃濬
(1890-1937).
Current location: The
Palace Museum 故宮博物館, Beijing.
|
Jicheng, 1.201.
Dong Chuping (1992),
26-39.
Shi (1998), # 9, 526.
Dong Shan (2014),
#69C.
|
|
j. Bell of Prince
Zhejian 者减鐘 (Jicheng, 1.202).
|
Same as above.
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
Kaogu (1979.1): 63, Fig. 2.
Jicheng, 1.202.
Dong Chuping (1992),
26-39.
Shi (1998), #10, 527.
Dong Shan (2014),
#69A-B.
|
|
*2. Bell of King
Guang of Wu 吳王光鍾 (Jicheng, 1.223).
|
Excavated 1955; Tomb
of Lord Shen of Cai 蔡侯申 (identified as Lord Zhao of Cai 蔡昭侯, r. 519–491 BCE). The tomb of Lord Zhao of Cai 蔡昭侯墓, inside the West Gate西門
of Shouxian 壽縣, Anhui. Current location:
National Museum of China中國國家博物館, Beijing.
|
Jicheng, 1.223.
Shi, #11, 527. – Is
this Cai or Wu? Shi thinks it’s Wu
|
|
*3. Broken Bell of
King Guang of Wu 吳王光殘鍾 (Jicheng, 1.224).
|
Excavated 1955; Tomb
of Lord Shen of Cai 蔡侯申 (identified as Lord Zhao of Cai 蔡昭侯, r. 519–491 BCE). The tomb of Lord Zhao of Cai 蔡昭侯墓, inside the West Gate西門
of Shouxian 壽縣, Anhui. Current Location:
Current location: Anhui Provincial Museum 安徽省博物館,
Hefei 合肥.
|
Jicheng, 1.224. (Cai)
Shi (1998), #12,
527-9. (Wu)
Dong Shan (2014), #
21; 27, 27n1. (Wu)
Feng, 122. (Wu)
|
|
*4. Nine Bells of
Zangsun of Gouwu 臧孫鐘.
|
|
*a-h. Bell of Zangsun
of Gouwu 减孫鐘 (Jicheng, 1.93-101).
|
Excavated 1964;
Eastern Zhou tomb No.1 (M1:53-M1:61) 東周一號墓,
Chengqiao 程橋 , Liuhe County 六合縣, Jiangsu. Current location: Nanjing Museum 南京博物院.
|
Kaogu (1965.3): 100, Fig. 9:1.
Jicheng, 1.93-101.
Ma Chengyuan 馬承源 (1988), 4.549
Dong (1992), 80-83.
Shi, #13-21, 529-32.
Dong Shan,
#176A-B,79n1.
Feng, 124.
|
|
*1. Pei’er goudiao 配兒鉤鑃 (Jicheng, 2.426).
|
Excavated 1977; in
the southern foothills of Goutou mountain 狗頭山南麓,
located to the southwest of Shaoxing City 紹興,
Zhejiang.
Current location:
Zhejiang Provincial Museum 浙江省博物館, Hangzhou 杭州
|
Kaogu (1983.4): 371, Fig. 2 (right);
372, Fig. 3:2.
Ma Chengyuan (1988),
4.368
Jicheng, 2.426.
Shi, # 23, 533.
Dong Shan, #179,80n2.
Feng, 122
|
|
*2. Pei’er goudiao 配兒鉤鑃 (Jicheng, 2.427).
|
Same as above
|
Kaogu (1983.4): 371, Fig. 2 (right);
372, Fig. 3:2.
Ma Chengyuan (1988),
4.368
Jicheng, 2.427.
Shi, # 24, 533.
Dong Shan, #179,80n2.
|
|
IV. Vessels
|
|
*1. Pan of Taishou of
Gouwu 工𫊣大叔盤 (1988).
|
Excavated 1988,
Eastern Zhou tomb No.3 東周三號墓, Chengqiao 程橋,
Liuhe County 六合縣, Jiangsu. Current location:
Nanjing Museum 南京博物院.
|
Shi, # 26, 534.
Dong Shan, #181,82n1.
3. Feng, 121.
|
|
*1. Yi of Ji Sheng of
Gouwu 工䱷季生匜 (Jicheng, 16.10212).
|
Excavated 1985, Wang
Village 王莊, Jiupu Xiang-Village 舊鋪鄉, Xuyi County 盱眙縣,
Jiangsu. Current location: Huaiyin Museum淮陰博物館,
Huai’an 淮安, Jiangsu.
|
Jicheng, 16.10212.
Shi, # 27, 534.
Dong Shan, #184,83n2.
4. Feng, 121.
|
|
*2. Yi of Luo'er 羅兒匜 (1988)
|
Excavated 1988,
Eastern Zhou tomb No.3 (M3:6) 東周三號墓,
Chengqiao 程橋, Liuhe County六合縣, Jiangsu. Current location: Nanjing Museum 南京博物院.
|
Shi, #39, 538.
Dong Shan, #183,83n1.
|
|
*1. “Jian of King
Guang of Wu” 吳王光鑑 (Jicheng, 16.10298).
|
Excavated 1955. Tomb
of Lord Shen of Cai 蔡侯申, identified as Lord Zhao of Cai 蔡昭侯 (r. 519–491 BCE) 蔡昭侯墓,
Ximen 西門, Shouxian 壽縣,
Anhui. Current location: Anhui Provincial Museum 安徽省博物館,
Hefei 合肥.
|
Guo Morou, Kaogu
xuebao (1956.1), plate 8.
Ma Chengyuan (1988),
4.538.
Jicheng, 16.10298-99.
Dong (1992), 45-49.
Shi, # 28-9, 534-5.
Lin, #160-1
Dong Shan, #19-20.
Feng, 121.
|
|
*2. “Jian of King
Guang of Wu” 吳王光鑑 (Jicheng, 16.10299).
|
Same as above.
|
Same as above.
|
|
1. “Jian of King
Fuchai of Wu” 吳王夫差鑑 (Jicheng, 16.10296).
|
Unearthed during the
Tongzhi reign 同治 (1856-1875), in Mengwang village
蒙王村, in Daizhou 代州
(Present day Shanxi 山西). In the 1930s, in a private
collection in Beijing 北京莫氏曾藏.
Current location:
Unknown
|
Jicheng, 16.10296.
Shi, #30, 535-6.
Dong Shan, #43.
Feng, 123.
|
|
2. “Jian of King
Fuchai of Wu” 吳王夫差鑑 (Jicheng, 16.10294).
|
Unearthed in the
1940s, Liuli Pavilion 琉璃閣, Hui County 輝縣,
Henan. Current location: National Museum of China 中國國家博物館,
Beijing.
|
Jicheng, 16.10294.
Shi, #31, 536.
Dong Shan, #44.
Feng, 123.
|
|
3. “Jian of King
Fuchai of Wu” 吳王夫差鑑 (Jicheng, 16.10295).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Palace Museum 故宮博物院,
Beijing.
|
Jicheng, 16.10295.
Shi, #33, 526.
Dong Shan, #46.
|
|
4. “Jian of King
Fuchai of Wu” 吳王夫差鑑.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Found in Hui County 南輝縣, Henan. Current location:
Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
Shi, #32, 536.
Dong Shan, #45.
|
|
5. “Jian of King
Fuchai of Wu” 吳王夫差鑑.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Found in Hui County 南輝縣, Henan. Current location:
Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
Shi, #34, 536-7.
Dong Shan, #47.
|
|
1. “He of King
Fuchai of Wu” 吳王夫差盉.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Found in Hui County 南輝縣, Henan. Current location:
Shanghai Museum 上海博物館 (Donated by Eric Hotung).
|
Shi, #35, 537.
Dong Shan, #42.
|
|
1. “Wuwang qignshi fu”
吳王御士簠 (Jicheng, 9.4527).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Found in 1957, re-excavated in Wang Village 旺村,
northeast of 海淀區 Haidian district, Beijing.
Current location:
Capital Museum 首都博物館, Beijing.
|
Jicheng, 9.4527.
Shi, #37, 537-8.
Feng, 124.
|
|
1. Wuwang Ji ding”
吳王姬鼎, (Jicheng, 5.2600).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Collected from the southern suburbs of Xi’an 西安南郊,
Shaanxi. Current location: Xian City Center for Cultural Relics 西安市文物中心, Xi’an.
|
Jicheng, 5.2600.
Shi, #36, 537.
|
|
2. “Wuwang sun Wushi ding”
吳王孫無士鼎 (Jicheng, 4.2359).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Found in 1977 in the storage area of Gaowang Temple 高王寺,
in Zhifang Village 帋坊鄉, Fengxiang County 鳳翔縣, Shaanxi. Current location: Fengxiang Museum 鳳翔縣博物館.
|
Wenwu (1981.1): Plate 6:2.
Jicheng, 4.2359.
Shi, #38, 538.
Lin, 26, #162.
Dong Shan, #185, 83n3
Feng, 124.
|
|
3. Beliang jun guang ding”
卑梁君光鼎.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Unknown.
|
Jicheng, 4.2283.
Shi, #40, 538-9.
Dong Shan, #186,84n1.
|
Yue 越 Inscriptions
|
I. Weapons and shorter inscriptions of the Fifth
Century BCE
|
|
A. King Goujian of Yue 越王句踐 (r. 497 BCE–465 BCE)
|
|
1. “Sword of Goujian,
the Son of the King of Yue” 越王之子句踐劍 (Jicheng, 18.11594).
|
Provenance unknown.
Unearthed Early 20th Century, Shouxian 壽縣,
Anhui. Originally in the collection of Huang Jun 黃濬
(1890-1937) and Chen Rentao 陳仁濤 (1906-1968). Whereabouts
unknown.
|
1. Chen Rentao, 36.
2. Rong Geng (1964),
279-80,
301, Fig. 8.
3. Dong (1992),
200-202.
4. Zhang and Cao, 232
[#70].
5. Dong (1998), 103.
6. Shi, 569 [#121].
7. Lin, 22 [#70].
8. Wang, 5.
9. Cao (2014), 71-2,
Figs. 44,
73 [Yue #1].
10. Dong Shan, 44n1
[#71].
|
|
2. “Sword of Goujian,
the Son of the King of Yue” 越王之子句踐劍 (Jicheng, 18.11595).
|
Provenance unknown.
Unearthed early 20th century. Shouxian. Originally in the collection of
Huang Jun 黃濬 (1890-1937). Current location:
Sackler Museum, Harvard University (1945).
|
1. Zhang and Cao, 233
[#71].
2. Dong (1998), 103.
3. Shi, 570 [#122].
4. Lin, 22 [#71].
5. Wang, 5-6.
6. Cao (2014), 72-3,
Figs. 45,
73 [Yue # 2].
7. Dong Shan, 45
[#72].
|
|
*3. “Sword of King
Goujian of Yue” 越王句踐劍 (Jicheng, 18.11621).
|
Excavated 1965, Tomb
No.1 一號墓, Wangshan 望山,
Jiangling County 江陵縣, Hubei. Current location: Hubei
Provincial Museum 湖北省博物館.
|
1. Wenwu (1966.5): 36,
Fig. 1, 41,
plates 1-3.
2. Dong (1992),
202-205.
3. Zhang and Cao, 234
[#72].
4. Dong (1998), 104.
5. Shi, 570 [#123].
6. Lin, 22, #72.
7. Wang, 6-7.
8. Feng, 124.
9. Cao (2014), 72,
74-75; Figs.
46, 75 [Yue #3].
10. Dong Shan, 45
[#73].
|
|
B. Weapons from 464-459 BCE, Reign of King
Zhezhi Yuyi 者旨於睗
|
|
1. “Dagger-axe of
King Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗戈.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Unearthed in the early 20th century in Shouxian 壽縣,
Anhui. Current location: Tokyo National Museum 東京国立博物館.
Originally in the collection of Chen Rentao 陳仁濤,
1906－1968.
|
1. Zhang and Cao, 234
[#79].
2. Dong (1998), 112.
3. Shi, 570-1 [#124].
4. Lin, 23 [#79].
5. Cao (2014), 89;
Fig. 68, 92 [Yue
# 25].
6. Dong Shan, 47
[#76].
|
|
*2. “Dagger-axe of
King Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗戈 (Jicheng, 17.11310).
|
Excavated 1959,
Zhanguo tomb # 2 二號墓, N of Cai Family Hill 蔡家崗, Zhao family burial mound 趙家孤堆,
Huainan 淮南, Anhui. Current location: Anhui
Provincial Museum 安徽省博物館, Hefei 合肥.
|
Cao Jinyan (2014),
Yue # 23, 84 and 89, Fig. 66, 87.
Dong (1992), 222-227.
Dong Chuping (1998),
111-112.
Dong Shan, #74, 47n2.
Lin, 23, #77.
Kaogu (1963.4): 209, Fig. 4.
Rong Geng (1964),
279; 300-1, Fig. 7.
Shi, #125, 571.
Feng, 125.
|
|
*3. “Dagger-axe of
King Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗戈 (Jicheng, 17.11311).
|
Same as above
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 24,
89, Fig. 67, 91.
Dong (1992), 222-227.
Dong (1998), 111-112.
Dong Shan, #75, 47n3.
Lin, 23, #78.
Kaogu (1963.4): 208, Fig. 3.
Shi, #126, 571.
|
|
1. “Spear of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗矛 (Jicheng, 17.11511).
|
Provenance unknown.
Unearthed in Shouxian 壽縣, Anhui. Current location: Eisei
Bunko Museum 永青文庫, Tokyo.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 26,
93; Fig. 69, 94.
Dong (1992), 217.
Dong (1998), 110.
Dong Shan, #77, 48n1.
Lin, 22, #73.
Rong (1964), 278;
298, Fig. 4.
Shi, #127, 571-2.
Zhang and Cao, #74,
236.
|
|
*2. “Spear of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗矛 (1988).
|
Excavated 1988; Tomb
2582, East side of Jiefang Road 解放路東側,
Luoyang 洛陽市, Henan. Current location:
Luoyang Municipal Archaeological Team 洛陽市文物工作隊
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 27,
93; Fig. 70, 95.
Dong (1998), 111.
Dong Shan, #78, 48n2.
Lin, 22, #74.
Shi, #128, 572.
Zhang and Cao, #73,
235.
Kaogu (1989.5): 415, Fig. 3 and # 5
[414-7].
Feng, 125.
|
|
3. “Spear of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗矛 (Jicheng, 18.11512).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #30;
97; Fig. 73, 99.
Dong (1992), 218.
Dong (1998), 110-11.
Dong Shan, #79, 48n3.
Lin, 22, #75.
Shi, #129, 572.
Zhang and Cao, #75,
237.
|
|
4. “Spear of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗矛.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Zhishui Gallery 止水齋,
Hangzhou 杭州, Zhejiang.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 28,
93; Figs. 71, 96.
Dong Shan, #138,
65n1.
Lin, 22, #76.
Shi, #130.
Zhang and Cao (1994),
#76, 238.
|
|
5. “Spear of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗矛.
|
Unclear provenance.
Unearthed in Shaoxing. Current location: Shaoxing History Museum 紹興越國文化博物館.
|
Cao Jinyan (2014),
Yue # 29, 93 and 97; Figs. 72, 98.
Dong Shan, #80, 48n4.
|
|
6. “Spear of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨矛.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Appeared on the Hong Kong market in 1992. Current location: Art Museum of the
Chinese University of Hong Kong 香港中文大學文物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue #31,
97; Figs. 74, 99.
Dong (1998), 111.
|
|
1. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍 (Jicheng, 18.11600).
|
Unearthed in the
1930s, Shouxian 壽縣, Anhui.
Originally in the
collection of Huang Jun 黃濬 (1890-1937), Beijing 尊古齋, then in the collection of the Shanghai Museum.
Current location:
National Museum of China 中國國家博物館, Beijing.
|
Cao (2014), # 21, 83;
Fig. 64, 86.
Dong (1992), 215.
Dong (1998), 109-110.
Dong Shan, #82, 48n6,
picture looks slightly different, but it’s apparently the same object as the
others.
Lin, 26, 158.
Rong (1964), 279;
300, Fig. 6.
Shi, #131, 572-73.
Wang, 10.
Zhang and Cao, #158,
250.
Feng, 125.
|
|
2. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance unknown.
Unearthed in the early 20th century in Shouxian 壽縣,
Anhui. Current location: unknown
|
Dong Shan, # 90,
49n8- which explains the discrepancy and #11600.
Lin, 23, #81 (Lin
calls this JC 11600, confusing it with the item above).
Rong (1964), 279;
300, Fig. 6.
Shi, #132, 573.
Wang, 12
Zhang and Cao, #81,
244.
|
|
3. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍 (Jicheng, 18.11597).
|
Provenance unknown.
Unearthed in the early 20th century in Shouxian 壽縣,
Anhui. Originally in the collection of Werner Jannings (Yang Ningshi 楊寧史) (1886-after 1954) of Germany. Current location:
Palace Museum 故宮博物院, Beijing.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #6,
76-77; Fig. 49, 79.
Dong Shan, #86, 49n4.
Lin, 27, 184.
Shi, #133, 573.
Wang, 9.
|
|
4. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍 (Jicheng, 18.11599;
18.11598).
|
Unearthed in 1930s,
Shouxian 壽縣, Anhui. Originally in the
collection of Huang Jun 黃濬 (1890-1937). Current location:
Shanghai Musuem 上海博物館.
|
Cao, Yue #7, 77; Fig.
50, 79.
Dong (1992), 213.
Dong (1998), 109.
Dong Shan, #81, 48n5.
Lin, 23, #83; 26,
#157.
Rong (1964), 278-9;
300, Fig. 5.
Shi, #134, 573-4.
Wang, 10.
Zhang and Cao, #83,
246; #157, 249.
|
|
5. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍 (Jicheng, 18.11596).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Originally in the collection of Fu Dayou 傅大卣
(1917-1994). Current location: Palace Museum 故宮博物院,
Beijing.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #10,
77; Fig. 53, 80.
Dong (1992), 214.
Dong (1998), 109.
Dong Shan, # 93,
49n11.
Lin, 23, #82.
Shi, #135, 574.
Wang, 9-10.
Zhang and Cao, #82,
245.
|
|
*6. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍 (1986).
|
Excavated 1986. Chu
Tomb No.9 九號楚墓, Guanping Village 官坪村, Yutai Xiang 雨臺鄉,
Jiangling County 江陵縣, Jingzhou 荆州,
Hubei. Current location: Jingzhou Museum 荆州地區博物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue #4,
74-76, Fig. 47, 75.
Dong (1992), 215-6.
Dong (1998), 110.
Dong Shan, #85, 49n3.
Lin, 23, #84.
Shi, #136, 574.
Wang, 10.
Jiang Han Kaogu (1989.3): plates 2 and 3.
[1-7+29+97-99].
Zhang and Cao, #84,
247
Feng, 125.
|
|
*7. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍 (1996).
|
Excavated 1996; Tomb
No.3 in Xiquan Cemetery 西圈墓地3號墓,
Nanguan Village 南關村, Shouchun 壽春,
Shouxian 壽縣, Anhui (The Tomb of a Cai
Elite). Current location: Shouxian Museum 壽縣博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 5,
76; Figs. 48, 79.
|
|
8. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection in Hong Kong.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #15,
78; Figs. 58, 82.
Dong Shan, #88, 49n6.
Lin, 27, #185.
Shi, #137, 574.
|
|
9. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍 (1996).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Appeared on the Hong Kong Market in 1996. Current location: Zhejiang
Provincial Museum 浙江省博物館, Hangzhou.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 9,
77; Fig. 52, 79.
Dong (1998), 108.
Dong Shan, #84, 49n2.
Lin, 27, 186
Shi, #138, 574.
Wenwu (1996.4): 6, Fig. 2, Color
Insert #1:1 and 2.
|
|
10. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection, Gaoxiong 高雄,
Taiwan.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #13,
78; Fig. 56, 81.
Dong Chuping (1998),
110.
Dong Shan, #89, 49n7.
Lin, 23, #85.
Shi, #139, 574-575.
Wang, 10.
Zhang and Cao, #85,
248.
|
|
11. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection, Hong Kong
|
Cao (2014), Yue #14,
78; Fig. 57, 82.
Dong Shan, # 92,
49n10.
Shi, #140, 575.
|
|
12. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍 (1995).
|
Provenance Unknown.
In 1995 collected by the Shanghai Museum from Hong Kong. Current location:
Shanghai Museum 上海博物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue #8,
77; Fig. 51, 80.
Dong Shan, #83, 49n1.
Wang, 10-11, Fig. 3.
|
|
13. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍 (1996/7).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Appeared 1996/7, Zhejiang. Current location: private collection, Wang Zhenhua
王振華, Gu Yue ge 古越閣 (“Ancient Yue Pavilion”), Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Cao, Wenwu
(Jan 2000): 70-73, 71, Fig.1.1.
Cao (2014), Yue #11,
77-78; Fig. 54, 81.
Dong (1998), 110.
Dong Shan, # 91,
49n9.
Wang, 11-12
|
|
14. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Zhenqin Gallery 珍秦齋, Macau.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #12,
78; Fig. 55, 81.
Dong Shan, #87, 49n5.
|
|
15. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection of Xu Zhouli 徐州李
in Jiangsu
|
Cao Jinyan (2014),
Yue #16, 78; Figs. 59, 82
|
|
16. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection of a certain Li 李
in Beijing
|
Cao (2014), Yue #17,
83; Figs. 60, 85.
|
|
17. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Collected by the museum in 2012. Current location: Shaoxing Museum 紹興市博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #18,
83; Figs. 61, 85.
|
|
18. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection of Luo Hewan 漯河宛,
Henan.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #19,
83; Figs. 62, 85.
|
|
19. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection of a certain Li 李
in Suzhou
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 20,
83; Figs. 63, 86.
|
|
20. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue” 越王者旨於睗劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Collected locally by the Shaoxing Museum in 2009.
Current location:
Shaoxing Museum 紹興縣博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 22,
84; Figs. 65, 86.
|
|
1. “Belt hook of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yuyue” 於越王者旨於睗帶鉤
|
Dong Shan is unclear,
claims it was unearthed on Xi Shi Mountain 西施山,
in the eastern suburbs of Shaoxing, 紹興. No site
report.
|
Dong Shan, # 95, 50
(references Cao Jinyan as the first to record this piece, but does not
provide any citation).
|
|
C.
Weapons from 458 BCE–449 BCE, Reign of King Bushou不壽
|
|
1. “Spear of Bushou,
the son the king of Yue” 越王大子不壽矛 (Jicheng, 18.11544).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Originally in the collection of Sun Ding 孫鼎.
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #32,
97, 100-102; Fig. 75, 100.
Dong (1992), 219-221.
Dong (1998), 114.
Dong Shan, #137,
63n3.
Lin, 25 #146.
Shi, #162, 581-2.
Zhang and Cao, #146,
327.
|
|
1. “Sword of King
Bushou of Yue” 越王不壽劍 (2001).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Originally in a private collection of a certain Chen 陳
in Taipei. In 2001, entered private collection in Taipei. Current location:
Private collection of Gong Qinlong 龔欽龍, Taipei, Taiwan
|
Cao, Wenwu
(2002.2): 66-69.
Cao (2014), Yue #33,
102-104; Fig. 76, 103.
Dong Shan, 51, 51n1
(forgery).
Wang, 12-13, Fig. 5.
|
|
C2. Swords from 458 BCE–449 BCE, reign of King Jibeigu 丌北古
|
|
1. “Sword of King
Jibeigu of Yue” 越王丌北古劍 (Jicheng, 18.11703).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 92,
148-51; Fig. 135, 150.
Dong Chuping (1992),
227-229.
Dong Shan, # 96,
51n2.
Lin, 24 #118.
Ma Chengyuan, Wenwu
(1962.12): 51-55, Fig. 1-4.
Rong (1964), 280;
301, Fig. 9.
Shi, #142, 575-6.
Wang, 23-4.
Zhang and Cao, #118,
287.
|
|
*2. “Sword of King
Jibeigu of Yue” 越王丌北古劍 (1987).
|
Excavated 1987,
Zhanguo tomb, 第二自來水廠工地, 東王家山,
迎江寺, Anqing 安慶,
Anhui. Current location: Anqing Museum 安慶市博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 93,
151; Figs. 138, 152.
Dong Shan, # 97,
51n3.
Lin, 27, 188.
Shi, #143, 576.
Wang, 24-25.
Feng, 125.
|
|
3. “Sword of King
Jibeigu of Yue” 越王丌北古劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Private Collection in Shaoxing
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 94,
151; Fig. 137, 153.
|
|
4. “Sword of King
Jibeigu of Yue” 越王丌北古劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Hainan Provincial Museum 海南省博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 95,
151 and 154; Fig. 138, 155.
|
|
5. “Sword of King
Jibeigu of Yue” 越王丌北古劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Private Collection Beijing
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 96,
154; Fig. 139, 155.
|
|
6. “Sword of King
Jibeigu of Yue” 越王丌北古劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Private Collection Beijing
|
Dong Shan, # 99,
51n5.
(is this the same as
above?)
|
|
7. “Sword of King
Jibeigu of Yue” 越王丌北古劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection, Wang Zhenhua 王振華,
Gu Yue ge 古越閣 (“Ancient Yue Pavilion”). Taipei,
Taiwan.
|
Dong Shan, # 98,
51n4.
|
|
8. “Sword of King
Jibeigu of Yue” 越王丌北古劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
|
Dong Shan, #100, 52.
|
|
D. Weapons from 448 BCE–412 BCE, Reign of King
Zhougou 州句
|
|
1. “Spear of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句矛 (Jicheng, 18.11535).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: British Museum, London. Originally in the collection of W.
Watson.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #63
118; Fig. 106, 121.
Dong (1992), 247.
Dong (1998), 120-121.
Dong Shan, #126,59n1.
Lin, 24, #102.
Rong (1964), 280;
303, Fig. 10.
Shi, #145, 576.
Zhang and Cao, #102,
267.
|
|
*1. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11625).
|
Excavated 1973; Chu
Tomb No.1 一號楚墓, Tengdian 藤店,
Jiangling County 江陵縣, Jingzhou 荆州,
Hubei. Jingzhou Museum 荆州地區博物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue #34,
104-106; Fig. 77, 105.
Dong (1992), 236-8.
Dong (1998), 118.
Dong Shan, #103,54n3.
Wenwu (1973.9): plate 1:3 [7-13;
plates].
Lin, 23, #86.
Shi, #146, 576-7.
Wang, 14, Fig. 6.
Zhang and Cao, #86,
252.
Feng, 126.
|
|
*2. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11631).
|
Excavated 1977. Chu
Tomb No.42 四十二號楚墓, Heshan miao 赫山廟, Yiyang 益陽市, Hunan
Hunan Provincial
Museum 湖南省博物館, Changsha.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 56,
112; Fig. 99, 116.
Dong (1992), 242.
Dong (1998), 119.
Dong Shan, #121,
56-7n1.
Lin, 23, # 97.
Shi, #147, 577.
Wang, 14
Zhang and Cao, # 97,
263.
Feng, 126.
Hunan kaogu jikan 湖南考古輯刊
(1982): 88, Fig. 1:4 [87-99,127.].
|
|
3. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11622).
|
Bought by Wang Yirong
王懿榮 in Xi’an 西安,
Shaanxi in 1881. Palace Museum 故宮博物院,
Beijing.
Originally in the
collection of Wang Yirong 王懿榮 (1845–1900), 陶祖光 Tao Zuguang (1882-1956), and Huang Jun 黃濬
(1890-1937).
|
Cao (2014), Yue #31,
106; Fig. 80, 108.
Dong (1992), 242.
Dong (1998), 119.
Dong Shan,
#104,54-5n1.
Lin, 23 [#88].
Rong (1964), 281; 302,
Fig. 11.
Shi, #148, 577.
Wang, 15.
Wang Yirong.
Perceval Yetts
(1934): 547-552, Figure 2-3.
Zhang and Cao, #88,
254.
Zou An (1916):
6.105.3-6.106.2.
|
|
4. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11624).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Early 20th Century, Shouxian. Originally in the collection of G.L.
Winthrop (1864-1943). 1943 entered into the collection of the Fogg Art
Museum, Harvard. Current location: Sackler Museum, Harvard University.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #38,
106; Fig. 81, 108.
Dong (1992), 243-4.
Dong (1998), 119.
Dong Shan, #105, 55n2
Lin, 23, # 96.
Rong (1964), 282;
303, Fig. 13.
Shi, #149, 577-8.
Wang, 16.
Zhang and Cao, # 96,
262.
|
|
*5. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11623 and
18.11629 are mixed up).
|
Unearthed in 1936,
Chu Tomb outside the gate of Xiaowu 小吳門外楚墓,
Changsha 長沙, Hunan.
Current location:
Shanghai Museum – Dong (1992), 245.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #41,
107; Fig. 84, 109.
Dong (1992), 244-45.
Dong (1998), 119.
Dong Shan, #106,
55n3. (Harvard)
Lin, 23, #87.
Rong (1964), 282;
304, Fig. 14.
Shi, #150, 578.
Wang, 16.
Zhang and Cao, #87,
253.
Feng, 126.
|
|
6. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11623 and
18.11629 are mixed up).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Early 20th Century, Shouxian 壽縣,
Anhui. Originally in the collection of Chen Rentao 陳仁濤
(1906－1968), O. Karlbook of Sweden
(Shi, 1998). Current location: Whereabouts unknown – Shi
(1998), Cao (1994).
Now in the Sackler Museum, Harvard University – Cao (2014)
|
Cao (2014), Yue #39,
106-7; Fig. 82, 109.
Dong Shan, #107,
55n4.
Lin, 23, #89.
Shi, #151, 578.
Zhang and Cao, #89,
255.
|
|
7. “Sword of the King
of Yue” 越王劍 (Jicheng, 18.11570).
|
Unearthed in 1931 in
Shaanxi.
Originally in the
collection of Rong Geng 容庚 (1894－1983),
Shigu Gallery 式古齋 in Beijing, Yu Xingwu 于省吾 (1896-1984).
Current location:
Guangzhou Museum 廣州市博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #62,
118; Fig. 105, 120.
Dong Shan, #150,
74n4.
Lin, 24, #106.
Rong (1964), 275-6;
298, Fig. 1.
Shi, #141, 575.
Zhang and Cao, #106,
271.
Feng, 125.
|
|
*8. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11632).
|
Excavated 1980;
Xiangxi Township 香溪鎮, Zigui County 秭歸縣, Hubei Current location: Zigui Qu Yuan Memorial
Hall 秭歸屈原紀念館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #36,
106; Fig. 79, 108.
Dong (1992), 238-9.
Dong Shan, #108,
55n5.
Lin, 23, # 95.
Shi, #152, 578-9.
Wang, 14, Fig. 6.
Zhang and Cao, # 95,
261.
Feng, 126.
|
|
*9. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (1987).
|
Excavated 1987, Chu
tomb No.36 (M36:4) 三十六號楚墓, Ziling gang 子陵崗, in the northern outskirts of Jingmen 荊門市北郊, Hubei. Current location: Jingmen Museum 荊門市博物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue #35,
106; Fig. 78, 108.
Feng, 126.
Jiang Han kaogu (1990.4): 5, Fig. 7: 4, Plate 2:
8 and 9.
Dong (1992), 239-10.
Dong (1998), 118.
Dong Shan, #109,
55n6.
Lin, 23-4, # 99.
Shi, #153, 579.
Wang, 14, Fig. 6.
Zhang and Cao, # 99,
265.
|
|
10. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11630).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #42,
107; Fig. 85, 109.
Dong Shan, #110,
55n7.
Lin, 23, # 93.
Shi, #154, 579.
Wang, 15.
Zhang and Cao, # 93,
259.
|
|
11. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11626).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Zhejiang Provincial Museum 浙江省博物館,
Hangzhou 杭州. Originally in the collection of
Huang Jun 黃濬 (1890-1937), Zungu gallery 尊古齋, Zhang Naiqi 章乃器
(1897–1977).
|
Cao Jinyan (2014),
Yue #44, 107 and 110; Fig. 87, 113.
Dong (1992), 236-8.
Dong (1998), 120.
Dong Shan, #111,
55n8.
Lin, 23, # 92.
Shi, #155, 579.
Wang, 14.
Zhang and Cao, # 92,
258.
|
|
12. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Private Collection in Hong Kong
|
Dong Shan, #112,
55n9.
Lin, 24, #100.
Shi, #156, 579.
Zhang and Cao, #100,
266.
|
|
13. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Guyue ge 古越閣, Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 53,
111-2; Fig. 96, 115.
Dong Shan, #119,
56n7.
Wenwu (1993): 18-28, Fig.1 and 2.
Lin, 23, # 90.
Shi, #157, 579-80.
Zhang and Cao, # 90,
256.
|
|
14. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11627).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Originally in the collection of Liu Tizhi劉體智 (1879~1962). Now in the National Palace Museum 臺北故宮博物院, Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 51,
111; Fig. 94, 115.
Dong (1992), 245-6.
Dong Shan, #120,
56n8.
Lin, 23, # 91.
Rong (1964), 282;
304, Fig. 15.
Shi, #158, 580.
Wang, 15.
Zhang and Cao, # 91,
257.
|
|
15. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11628).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Originally in the collection of M. Jacques Orcel. Now in
the Musée Cernuschi, Paris.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #40;
107; Fig. 83, 109.
Dong (1992), 243.
Dong (1998), 120.
Dong Shan, #113,
55-56n1.
Lin, 23, # 94.
Rong (1964), 281;
303, Fig. 12.
Shi, #159, 580.
Wang, 16.
Zhang and Cao, # 94,
260.
|
|
16. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance unclear.
Unearthed in Zhejiang in the 1990s. Once in the Gu Yuege 古越閣, Taipei. Private collection of a certain Gong 龔
in Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Cao (1997).
Cao (2014), Yue # 57,
112 and 117; Fig. 100, 116.
Dong Shan, #125,
57n5.
Lin, 27, 190.
Shi, #160, 580-81.
Wang, 17-18.
|
|
17. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 戉王州句劍 (Jicheng, 18.11579).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: National Museum of China 中國國家博物館,
Beijing.
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 59,
117-8; Fig.102, 120.
Dong Shan, #124, 57n4.
Lin, 23, # 98.
Shi, #161, 581.
Zhang and Cao, #98,
264.
|
|
18. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #43,
107; Figs. 86, 113.
Dong Shan, #115, 56n3
|
|
19. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Macau, Zhenqin gallery 珍秦齋
|
Cao (2014), Yue #45,
110; Figs. 88, 113.
Dong Shan, #116, 56n4
|
|
20. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection of a certain Zhu 朱
in Hangzhou.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #46,
110; Figs. 89, 114.
|
|
21. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #47,
110; Figs. 90, 114.
Dong Shan #117, 56n5
|
|
22. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Art Museum of the Chinese University of Hong Kong 香港中文大學文物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue #48,
110-1; Figs. 91, 114.
Wang, 18.
Dong Shan, #118, 56n6
|
|
23. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection of Xu Zhouli 徐州李
in Jiangsu.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #49,
111; # 92, 114.
|
|
24. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection of a certain Li 李
in Beijing
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 50,
111; # 93, 115.
|
|
25. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 52,
111; Figs. 95, 115.
Dong Shan, #114, 65n2
|
|
26. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection of a certain Liu 劉
in Changsha
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 54,
112; # 97, 116.
|
|
27. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Unearthed in the
1970s in Shouxian 壽縣, Anhui. Once in the collection
of Jiya Hall 集雅堂舊藏Current location: unknown.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #55,
112; # 98, 116.
|
|
28. “Sword of King
Zhougou of Yue” 越王州句劍.
|
Provenance unclear,
recently unearthed in Shaoxing. Current location: Shaoxing Museum 紹興縣博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #58,
117; #101, 117.
|
|
1. “Iron sword of
King Gou of Yue” 越王句鐵劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Once in the Private
Collection of Wang Zhengua 王振華, Gu Yue ge 古越閣 (“Ancient Yue Pavilion”). Current location: Private
collection of a certain Gong 龔, Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #60,
118; Fig. 103, 120.
Dong Shan, #101,
54n1.
Wenwu #8 (1995): 94-96, Fig. 4.
Lin, 23, #80 and 27,
189 (are they the same?)
Shi, #144, 576. (Lin
does not reference Shi)
Zhang and Cao, #80,
251.
|
|
2. “Iron sword with
Bronze Guard of Zhougou of Yue” 越州丩鐵劍銅格.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: 珍秦齋, Macau
|
Cao (2014), Yue #61,
118; Figs. 104, 120.
Dong Shan, #102,
54n2.
|
|
II. Weapons of later kings (late 5th to 4th
centuries),
and
uncertain and disputed shorter inscriptions.
|
|
A. Weapons of Zhi Buguang 旨不光, 旨翳不光 Zhiyi
Buguang, Zhiyi 旨翳, Zhezhi Buguang者旨不光, and
Buguang 不光 (Heir of
the King of Yue越王嗣)
|
|
*1. “Sword of Zhi
Buguang Hereditary Heir of the King of Yue” 越王嗣旨不光劍
(Jicheng, 18.11704).
|
Excavated 1974,
Zhanguo Tomb, in Zhangjiashan 張家山, 城西門外 Jiangling County江陵縣,
Hubei. Current location: Jingzhou Museum 荆州地區博物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue #64,
122; Figs. 107, 125.
Dong (1992), 229.
Dong Shan, #135,
63n1.
Lin, 24, #107.
Shi, #163, 582.
Wang, 19-20.
Zhang and Cao, #107,
272.
Feng, 126.
|
|
2. “Sword of Zhi
Buguang Hereditary Heir of the King of Yue” 越王嗣旨不光劍
(Jicheng, 18.11642).
|
Unearthed in 1935,
Changsha.
Once in the
collection of O. Karlbrook of Sweden.
Current location: Shi
(1999): Whereabouts unknown; Cao (2014): private collection in Sweden.
|
Cao Jinyan (1999),
Yue #36; 88-90.
Cao Jinyan (2014),
Yue #65, 123; Fig. 108, 125.
Dong Shan, #133,
61n2.
Lin, 24, #108.
Shi, #164, 582.
Wang, 20.
Zhang and Cao, #108,
273.
|
|
3. “Sword of Zhi
Buguang Hereditary Heir of the King of Yue” 越王嗣旨不光劍
(Jicheng, 18.11641).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館
|
Cao, Wenwu
(1995.8):74, Fig. 2.1.
Cao (1999), Yue #37;
90.
Cao (2014), Yue #66,
123; Figs. 109, 126.
Dong Shan, #132,
61n1.
Lin, 24, #109.
Shi, #165, 583.
Wang, 19-20.
Zhang and Cao, #109,
274.
|
|
4. “Sword of Zhi
Buguang Hereditary Heir of the King of Yue” 越王嗣旨不光劍
(Jicheng, 18.11692).
|
Unearthed in the
1930s, Shouxian 壽縣. Originally in the collection of
Anhui, Chen Rentao 陳仁濤 (1906－1968).
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue #68,
123-4.
Dong Shan, #143, 71n1.
Lin, 24, #119.
Shi, #166, 583.
Zhang and Cao, #119,
283.
|
|
5. “Sword of Zhi
Buguang Hereditary Heir of the King of Yue” 越王嗣旨不光劍
(Jicheng, 18.11656).
|
Unearthed in the
1930s, Shouxian 壽縣, Anhui. Originally in the
collection of Liu Tizhi 劉體智 (1879~1962). Current location:
National Palace Museum 臺北故宮博物院, Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #69,
124.
Dong Shan, #145,
72n2.
Lin, 24, #120 and
121.
Shi, #167, 583.
Zhang and Cao, #120
and #121, 284, 285.
|
|
6. “Sword of Zhi
Buguang Hereditary Heir of the King of Yue” 越王嗣旨不光劍
(Jicheng, 18.11618).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Originally in the collections of Huang Jun 黃濬
(1890-1937) and Liu Tizhi 劉體智 (1879~1962).
Current location:
Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #70, 124.
Dong Shan, #146,
72n3.
Lin, 24, #116.
Shi, #168, 583-4.
Zhang and Cao, #116,
282.
|
|
7. “Sword of Zhi
Buguang Hereditary Heir of the King of Yue”越王嗣旨不光劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection in Shaoxing
|
Cao (2014), Yue #67,
123.
Dong Shan, #144,
71-72n1.
|
|
1. “Sword of King
Zhiyi Buguang of Yue” 越王旨翳不光 (Type A sword)
|
Provenance Unknown.
Appeared on the Hong Kong Antiquities Market in 1994. Cheung Kwong Yue 張光裕 of the Chinese University of Hong Kong 香港中文大學 made an epigraphic copy. Current location: private
Collection, Gaoxiong 高雄, Taiwan.
|
Cao, Wenwu
(2000.1), 71, Fig.1.4.
Cao Jinyan (2014),
Yue #73, 131.
Dong Shan, #127,
59n2.
Lin, 25, #148.
Shi, #171, 584.
Wang, 22.
Zhang and Cao, #148,
275.
|
|
*2. “Sword of King
Zhiyi Buguang of Yue” 越王旨翳不光 (2006).
|
Excavated 2006.
Zhanguo tomb No.30, Tianzi zhen 天子墳, Huxing
shan虎形山, Heshan district / He mountain
area 赫山區, Yiyang 益陽,
Hunan. Current location: Yiyang Museum
|
Cao (2014), Yue #72,
129-31.
|
|
1. “Sword of King
Zhiyi of Yue” 越王旨翳劍 (1998).
|
Unprovenanced; 1998,
Cheung Kwong Yue 張光裕 of the Chinese University of
Hong Kong 香港中文大學 epigraphic copy. Current
location: private collection, Gaoxiong 高雄,
Taiwan.
|
Cao, Wenwu
(2000.1), 71.
Cao (2014), Yue #71,
124, 130-31.
Dong Shan, #128,
59-60n1.
Wang, 22-23.
|
|
1. “Sword of King
Zhezhi Buguang of Yue” 越王者旨不光劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: private collection of a certain Zhu 朱
in Wuxi 無錫, Jiangsu
|
Cao (2014), Yue #74,
131.
|
|
1. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11645).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Originally in the collection of Liu Tizhi 劉體智
(1879~1962).
Current location:
Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #77,
132.
Dong Shan, #151,
75n1.
Lin, 24, #112.
Shi, #173, 584-5.
Wang, 21.
Zhang and Cao, #112,
278.
|
|
2. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11648).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: National Museum of China 中國國家博物館,
Beijing
|
Cao (2014), Yue #81,
136.
Dong Shan, #152,
75n2.
Lin, 27, 192.
Shi, #174, 585.
|
|
3. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11647).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #80,
136.
Dong Shan, #153,
75n3.
Lin, 27, 193.
Shi, #175, 585.
|
|
4. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11646).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shanghai Museum 上海博物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue #79,
136; Fig. 122.
Dong Shan, #154,
75n4.
Lin, 24, #113.
Shi, #176, 585.
Zhang and Cao, #113,
279.
|
|
5. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11644).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Palace Museum 故宮博物院,
Beijing.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #78,
136; Fig. 121.
Dong Shan, #155,
75n5.
Lin, 24, #115.
Shi, #177, 585-6.
Wang, 21-2.
Zhang and Cao, #115,
281.
|
|
*6. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11650).
|
Excavated 1979;
Zhanguo tomb No.4, Pingliangtai 平糧臺,
Huaiyang 淮陽, Hunan. Current location: Henan
Provincial Institute of Archaeology and Cultural Relics 河南省文物研究所.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #76,
132; Fig. 119.
Dong (1992), 230-34.
Dong Shan, #156,
75n6.
Lin, 24, #111.
Shi, #178, 586.
Wang, 20.
Zhang and Cao, #111,
277.
Feng, 126.
|
|
*7. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11649).
|
Same as above,
|
Cao (2014), Yue #75,
131-2; Fig. 118, 135.
Dong (1992), 230-4.
Dong Shan, #157,
75n7.
Lin, 24, #110.
Shi, #179, 586.
Wang, 21.
Zhang and Cao (1994),
#110, 276.
|
|
*8. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11664).
|
Same as above.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #82,
136-7; Fig. 125.
Dong (1992), 230-4.
Dong Shan, #158,
75n8.
Lin, 24, #114.
Shi, #180, 586.
Wang, 21.
Zhang and Cao, #114,
280.
|
|
9. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Shaoxing Museum 紹興縣博物館
|
Cao (2014), Yue #83,
137; Fig. 126.
|
|
10. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍 (Jicheng, 18.11667).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Palace Museum 故宮博物院,
Beijing.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #84,
137; Fig. 127.
Dong Shan, #159,
75n9.
Lin, 27, #194.
Shi, #181, 586-7.
|
|
11. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍.
|
Unearthed in Anhui.
Current location: Shaoxing Museum 紹興縣博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #85,
137; Fig. 128.
|
|
12. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Hanyue Hall 翰越堂,
Shaoxing
|
Cao (2014), Yue #86,
137-44; Fig. 139.
|
|
13. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
First described in Macau, 2008. Current location: private collection,
Shaoxing
|
Cao (2014), Yue #87,
144; Fig. 132, 146.
|
|
*14. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍 (2000).
|
Excavated 2000;
Zhanguo Tomb No. 1, Caojiashan 曹家山,
Jingzhou 荆州, Hubei. Current location:
Jingzhou Museum 荆州地區博物館.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #88,
144; Fig. 131, 147.
|
|
15. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location:
Academia Sinica 臺北中央研究院, Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #89,
144; Fig. 132, 147
|
|
16. “Sword of King
Buguang of Yue” 越王不光劍.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location:
private collection, Luohe, Henan
|
Cao (2014), Yue #90,
148; Fig. 133, 149.
|
|
B. Shorter Inscriptions, Dating uncertain
|
|
1. Sword of Yue 越劍
(Jicheng, 18.11655).
|
Provenance Unknown.
Originally in the collections of Chen Jieqi 陳介祺
(1813-1884) and Huang Jun 黃濬 (1890-1937). Current location:
unknown.
|
Cao (2014), #100,
157; Figs. 143, 158.
Dong (1992), 230-4.
Dong Shan, #129,
61n1.
Lin, 24, #117.
Shi, #182, 587.
Zhang and Cao, #117,
286.
|
|
2. “Broken Sword of
the King of Yue” 越王殘劍/ Sword 囗劍
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location:
private collection, Hong Kong
|
Cao (2014), Yue # 91,
148; Fig. 134, 149.
Dong Shan, #131,
61n3.
Lin, 27, 195.
Shi, #183, 587.
|
|
1. “Spear of the King
of Yue” 越王矛 (Jicheng, 18.11451).
|
Provenance unknown.
Found before 1949, Changsha, Hunan.
Current location:
Hunan Provincial Museum 湖南省博物館, Changsha.
|
Cao (2014), Yue #102,
157; Figs. 145, 159.
Dong Shan, #147,
74n1.
Lin, 24, #105.
Rong (1964), 276;
298, Fig. 2.
Shi, #184, 587.
Zhang and Cao, 270,
#105.
|
|
1. “Dagger-axe of the
King of Yue” 越王戈.
|
Provenance Unknown.
|
1. Zhang and Cao,
#69, 231.
2. Shi, #186, 588.
3. Lin, 22, #69.
4. Cao (2014), Yue
#103, 160,
Figs. 146, 161.
5. Dong Shan, #149,
74n3.
|
|
1. “Lance of the King
of Yue” 越王鈹 (Jicheng, 18.11571).
|
Provenance Unknown.
According to Cao (2014), collected from Hangzhou in 1972 by the Zhejiang
Museum. According to Shi (1998): 1976, Zhejiang, 1976, Yin County 鄞縣,
Zhejiang. Current location: Zhejiang Provincial Museum 浙江省博物館, Hangzhou 杭州.
|
1. Zhang and Cao,
#60, 228.
2. Shi, #185, 587-8.
3. Lin, 22, #66.
4. Cao (2014), Yue
#101, 157;
Figs. 144, 159.
5. Dong Shan, #148,
74n2.
|
|
C. Unprovenanced and
Contested
|
|
|
|
1. “Dagger-axe of
King Deju/Chaixu? of Yue” I
越王差䣄戈 /越王得居戈.
|
Unprovenanced,
apparently looted in the 1990s, Shaoxing. Unearthed along with second
dagger-axe, below. Current Location: private collection,
|
1. Cao (2007), 92-98.
2. Dong Shan, #140,
66n1.
|
|
2. “Dagger-axe of
King Deju/Chaixu? of Yue” II 越王差䣄戈 /越王得居戈.
|
|
1. Cao (2007), 92-98.
2. Dong Shan, #141,
66n2.
Same Note as above
|
|
3. “Sword of King
Zhezhi of Yue” 越王者旨劍
|
Provenance Unknown.
Current location: Beijing Bohua wensheng wenhua yishu gongsi 北京博華文盛文化藝術公司
|
Dong Shan, #70, 43n2.
|
|
4. “Chuwuyu sword” 初無余劍
|
Provenanced unknown.
First described in 1993. Current location: Gu Yue ge 古越閣,
Taipei
|
Dong Shan, 69n1
[#142].
|
|
III.
Bells
|
|
*1. Fragment of a
Shattered Bell with the Character Yu 於殘鐘
(Jicheng, 1.1).
|
Excavated 1960. Tomb
in Hengshan 横[土+扇](扇)古墓,
Wujiang County 吳江縣, Jiangsu. Current location:
Nanjing Museum 南京博物院.
|
1. Kaogu, #7 (1961):
390; plate 1.
2. Dong (1992), 161.
3. Dong (1998), 114.
4. Lin, 26, #167.
5. Shi, # 97, 557;
364.
6. Feng, 125.
7. Cao (2014), 272,
Fig. 246 附
|
|
2. Bell of King
Zhezhi Yuyi of Yue 越王者旨於睗鐘 (Jicheng, 1.144-Six
Facsimiles of the Inscription):
|
This bell (now lost),
was unearthed during the Song. It was once in the collection of Zhao
Zhongyuan 趙仲爰 (1054-1123), a member of the
Song imperial family. Later it was in the Song Imperial Treasury.
|
1. Bogu tulu
(1123).
2. Xue Shanggong
(1144) #1.
3. Xue Shanggong
(1144) #3.
4. Wang Qiu 王俅
(12th
century).
5. Ma Chengyuan
(1986-90).
6. Shi (1998), 98-99.
7. Cao (1994A).
8. Shi, #100 (1998).
9. Cao Jinyan (2014).
10. Dong Shan (2014),
# 94.
|
|
3. The Bell of King
Zhugou of Yue 朱句鐘 (Jicheng, 1.171).
|
Discovered 12th
century. Now lost. Originally in the Collection of Dong Wuzi 董武子 (d. 1137). Described with facsimile in Xue
Shanggong 薛尚功, ed., Lidai zhongding yiqi
kuanzhi fatie 歷代鐘鼎彝器款識法帖 (1144), 1.4-5 (p. 8).
|
1. Xue Shanggong.
2. Cao (1994).
3. Shi (1998).
4. Cao (2014).
5. Dong Shan (2014)
#194.
|
|
4. “Yue Bell with Odd
Characters” 越奇字鐘/ “Nengyuan Bo-Bell” 能原鎛 (Jicheng, 1.156).
|
Unearthed in 1890 in
Linjiang County 臨江縣, Jiangxi (Originally in the
collection of Lu Xinyuan 陸心源, Liu Tizhi 劉體智 (1879~1962). Later kept in Academia Sinica Museum 臺北中央博物館, Taipei). Current location: National Palace Museum 臺北故宮博物院, Taipei, Taiwan.
|
Zou An 鄒安
(1916), 1.33-35.
Jicheng, 1.155.
Zhang and Cao, #130,
297-301.
Shi, # 94, 555.
Cao (1999), #62,
117-8; 119-20, Fig. 89.
Lin, 25, #130.
Cao (2014), Yue (xia)
#3, 274-275; 276-7, Fig. 248.
Dong Shan, #191,
86n4.
Feng, 125.
|
|
5. “Yue bell with Odd
Characters” 越奇字鐘 “Nengyuan Bo-Bell” 能原鎛 (Jicheng, 1.155).
|
Guangxu, Year 16
(1890), Found by fishermen in Jinjiang 錦江
on the eastern outskirts Ruzhou 瑞州 (Present
day Gao’an 高安), Jiangxi (Originally in the
collection of Xiong Fangsui 熊方燧). Current location: Palace
Museum 故宮博物院, Beijing.
|
Zou An 鄒安
(1916), 1.45-47.
Jicheng, 1.156.
Zhang and Cao, #131,
302-5.
Shi, # 95, 555-6
Cao (1999), #63, 118;
122-3, Fig. 90.
Lin, 25, #130.
Cao (2014), Yue (下)
#4, 275, 280; 278-79, Fig. 249.
Dong Shan, #192,
86n5.
Feng, 125.
|
|
6. “Yue bell with Odd
Characters” 越奇字鐘.
|
Provenance Unknown.
Whereabouts unknown
|
Rong (1938), Fig. 21
Shi, 556-57; 360-63
[# 96].
Lin, 26, 166
Cao (2014), Yue (下)
# 5, 280-4, Fig. 250.
Dong Shan, 87n2
[#193].
|
|
1. The Goudiao-bell
of the son of Gufeng Guatong 姑馮𠯑同之子句鑃 (Jicheng, 2.424).
|
Found in Changshu
County, Jiangsu in 1788.
|
1. Zou An 鄒安
(1916), 1.78-79.
2. Jicheng, 2.424.
3. Dong (1992),
152-6.
4. Shi, 567-8 [#117].
5. Dong Shan, 84
[#188].
6. Feng, 124.
|
|
2. The Qici
Goudiao-bell 其次句鑃 (19th century (Jicheng,
2.422).
|
Unearthed on a
mountain in Wukang County 武康縣, Zhejiang.
Current location:
Palace Museum 故宮博物院, Beijing.
|
1. Zou An 鄒安
(1916), 1.81.
2. Jicheng, 2.422.
3. Dong (1992),
156-161.
4. Shi, 568 [#118].
5. Dong Shan, 86n3
[#190].
6. Feng, 124.
|
|
3. The Qici Goudiao
bell 其次句鑃 (19th century (Jicheng,
2.421).
|
Unearthed on a
mountain in Wukang County 武康縣, Zhejiang. Originally in the
collection of Su Huanong 蘇花農 and Xu Zishan 徐紫珊. Current location: unknown.
|
1. Zou An 鄒安
(1916), 1.80
2. Jicheng, 2.421
3. Dong (1992),
156-161.
4. Shi, 568-9 [#119].
5. Dong Shan, 86-7n1
[#189].
|
|
1. The Goudiao-bell
of the son of Gufeng Guatong 姑馮𠯑同之子句鑃 (Jicheng, 2.424).
|
Found in Changshu
County, Jiangsu in 1788.
|
1. Zou An 鄒安
(1916), 1.78-79.
2. Jicheng, 2.424.
3. Dong (1992),
152-6.
4. Shi, 567-8 [#117].
5. Dong Shan, 84
[#188].
6. Feng, 124.
|
|
IV. Vessels
|
|
1. The Zhili Fragment
of a Broken Tripod Cover 之利殘片
|
1. The Zhili Fragment
of a Broken Tripod Cover 之利殘片
|
1. The Zhili Fragment
of a Broken Tripod Cover 之利殘片
|
|
V. Mat Weight 席鎮 (xizhen)
|
|
*1. “Pengjiashan Mat
Weight” 彭家山席鎮
|
*1. “Pengjiashan Mat
Weight” 彭家山席鎮
|
*1. “Pengjiashan Mat
Weight” 彭家山席鎮
|
|
Zhedao
bo-bell 者𣱼鑮 (bó) and
Set of Twelve Zhedao zhong-bells 者𣱼鐘
(Associated with
Yue. In elongated Chu-style script without bird elements)
|
|
a. Zhedao Bo-bell 者𣱼鎛
(Jicheng, 1.120)
|
Unearthed in a tomb
in Jincun 金村, Luoyang 洛陽,,
Henan. Current Location: Suzhou Museum 蘇州市博物館
|
1. Wenwu (1992:2): 96, 104.
2. Jicheng,
1.120-32.
3. Dong (1992), 173,
Figs.170-
95.
4. Shi, 560-2
[#103-6], only
the extant
pieces.
5. Lin, 26 [#171-174]
only the
extant pieces)
6. Dong Shan, 88
[#195].
|
|
b. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.121)
|
Transmitted through
an tomb in Jincun 金村, Luoyang 洛陽,
Henan. Current Location: Sen-oku Hakukokan Museum, Tokyo, Japan 東京都泉屋博古館.
|
Same as above
|
|
c. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.122)
|
Transmitted through
an tomb in Jincun 金村, Luoyang 洛陽,
Henan. Current Location: Unknown
|
Same as above
|
|
d. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.123)
|
Same as above
|
Same as above
|
|
e. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.124)
|
Same as above
|
Same as above
|
|
f. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.125)
|
Same as above
|
Same as above
|
|
g. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.126)
|
Same as above
|
Same as above
|
|
h. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.127)
|
Same as above
|
Same as above
|
|
i. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.128)
|
Same as above
|
Same as above
|
|
j. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.129)
|
Same as above
|
Same as above
|
|
k. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.130)
|
Same as above
|
Same as above
|
|
l. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.131)
|
Same as above
|
Same as above
|
|
m. Zhedao Bell 者𣱼鐘
(Jicheng, 1.132)
|
Same as above.
Current location: Sen-oku Hakukokan Museum, Tokyo, Japan 東京都泉屋博古館 (originally in the collection of Chen Jieqi 陳介祺, 1813-1884).
|
Same as above
|
Wu Zhenfeng 吳鎮烽, “Ji xin faxian
de liang ba Wuwang jian” 記新發現的兩把吳王劍，Jianghan kaogu 江漢考古 (2009.3): 81-84.
Chen Rentao 陳仁濤, Jinkui lungu
chuji 金匱論古初集 (Hong Kong:
Yazhou shiyinju, 1952), 36.
Note: According
to Dong Shan, Wu Zhenfeng 吳鎮烽
argued that the inscription on this piece is a forgery, but provides no
citation, see Dong Shan, 51.
There is a lot of
confusion about this piece. Shi (1998), 578: Originally in the collection of
Cai Jixiang 蔡季襄 (1898-1979), G.L.
Winthorp. Now in the Sackler Museum, Harvard University. However, Cao (2014)
says it was once in the collections of Cai Jixiang 蔡季襄 (1898-1979) and Chen Rentao, then
went overseas. Once in the collectin of O. Karlbook of Sweden (1947). Wang
Jiehua notes its finding in 1936, and says it passed to Karlbrook, but Dong
Shan says it’s in the Shanghai Museum.
Dong Shan says
the inscription makes it look contemporary with Zhezhi Yuyi, see Dong Shan,
74n4 [#150].
Cao Jinyan 曹錦炎, “Ba guyuege
xincang zhi Zhougou mingwen” 跋古越閣新藏之州句劍銘文. Disan jie guoji Zhongguo guwen zixue
yantaohui wenji 第三屆國際中國古文字學研討會文集
(Hong Kong: Chinese University, 1997).
Cao Jinyan 曹錦炎, “Xin jian
Yuewang bingqi jiqi xiangguan wenti” 新見越王兵器及其相關問題, Wenwu (2000.1): 71, Fig.1.4.
Chen Bangfu 陳邦福, “Wujiang
Hengshan chutu Yuewang can zhong kaoshi” 吳江横(土扇)出土越王殘鐘考釋, Kaogu 考古, # 7 (1961): 390;
plate 1.
|
